Display MoreSince attack doesnt scale linearly vs defense values, there comes a point where u have so much attack compared to your targets defense that crit will always give you more dps.
But its more complicated than that when you factor in that crit also gives you less % increase per crit manastone the more crit you get.
To give an extreme and easy example would be:
You will always have more dps on a boss with 25 000 defense from attack stones.
On the contrary you will always do more dps on a lower end boss with 5000 defense from crit manastones.
There used to be a spreadsheet for different boss defense values and what manastone setup would be optimal for each class on each boss but that probably isnt updated anymore.
For pvp you basicly either have a higher rate of crits or a lower rate of crits which do more damage.
in a perfect world you slot full attack and every time you engage on someone you roll that 35% crit every single hit.
in the end its all up to preference and who you're fighting against and what defense they have.
Well put! Could not agree more